Honeywell Stops Taking Orders for Oxyfume Ethylene Oxide Sterilants
Honeywell announced in August 2012 that it would discontinue production of the Oxyfume ethylene oxide (EtO) sterilant gas cylinders because of Clean Air Act regulations from the EPA banning the sales and use of most HCFC based products like Oxyfume in the end of 2014.
On March 15th, Honeywell announced that they would no longer receive orders for Oxyfume after March 31st 2013 and that Oxyfume 2002 and Oxyfume 2000 cylinders should be sent to Honeywell for recycling until production ceases later this year. Cylinders of Oxyfume 12, a CFC-based product phased out in 1995, cannot be received by Honeywell and current and former customers should contact Honeywell for information on how to handle these cylinders.
Ethylene oxide used to be the dominant low temperature sterilant in healthcare and ethylene oxide blends were the primary means of delivering EtO. The blends were used because ethylene oxide is a flammable/explosive gas with a lower explosive limit of 3% v/v with mixtures being explosive up to 100%. Ethylene oxide explosions can cause major damage, as happened to Sterigenics in 2004; and so the ethylene oxide is diluted with an inert gas to make the mixture non flammable. Both carbon dioxide and chloroflorocarbons (CFCs) were used as the inert gas. Honeywell’s Oxyfume 12 contained 12% EtO and 88% CFC-12, (Dichlorodifluoromethane) which was banned under the Montreal Protocol, its manufacture was banned in the United States along with many other countries in 1996 due to concerns about damage to the ozone layer.
CFCs were replaced with hydrochloroflurocarbons (HCFCs) and Honeywell introduced the oxyfume 2000 which contained 8.6% EtO in 91.4% HCFC-124 (Chlorotetrafluoroethane) and the Oxyfume 2002 which contained 10% EtO, 27% HCFC-22 (Chlorodifluoromethane) and 63% HCFC-124. The switch to the HCFCs was a temporary measure and they in turn are being phased out under the revised Montreal Agreement.
Market forces are also acting against the EtO blends which held a dominant market position before the 1990s. Honeywell estimates that more than 70 percent of hospitals in the United States have used Oxyfume in their sterilization facilities over the last 40 years. In 1993 Advanced Sterilization Products (ASP) launched its Sterrad hydrogen peroxide sterilizer which offered much shorter cycle times compared to the ~ 15 hours required for EtO sterilization and aeration and ASP’s marketing emphasized the carcinogenic properties of EtO (even though the OSHA permissible exposure limits for EtO and hydrogen peroxide vapor are the same 1 ppm time weighted average over 8 hours).
The Sterrad system offered significant safety features, particularly by operating under reduced pressure (leaks will be in not out) and newer EtO sterilizers were introduced by 3M and Steris Corporation that also operated at reduced pressure and used single use cartridges. Both of these measures served to reduce employee exposure to EtO compared to the older pressurized systems. The single use cartridges uses a small quantity (100 – 170g) of 100% EtO and so do not use the HCFC blends and avoid the need to run gas lines and change EtO gas cylinders.
There has been a lot of confusion over the years about whether EtO was being phased out. It is not! It is the CFC and HCFC blend gases that are being phased our to protect the stratospheric ozone layer. EtO is still the major gas sterilant used by medical device manufacturers because it can be used for sterilization of almost all medical devices including plastic and heat sensitive materials.
EtO is not going away; the world production of EtO was 19 million tonnes in 2008 and 18 million tonnes in 2007 which places EtO as the 14th most produced organic chemical; and the amount of EtO used for sterilization is a minuscule fraction of this production. Even though EtO use in healthcare has dropped in the last two decades, there are still many hospitals that use EtO as for low temperature sterilization and it is likely that EtO will continue to be an important low temperature sterilant gas for the foreseeable future.